pete
Super Member
Registered: Jun 29, 2021 13:48:10 GMT -7
Posts: 409
|
Post by pete on Jan 4, 2022 18:29:43 GMT -7
If you followed along with the "Bobby Allison Coke Charger" build thread. You have a pretty good idea of this kits strong/weak points. If not, well, I will re-cap the good, bad and ugly for you here. The good: Its a great subject for openers. Its molded in white plastic. It is proportionally accurate. The body and all panels that fit to it fit...Really well. The chrome bumpers locate well and tightly to their respective notches in the body. Even the glass locates positively against the inside of the roof, A and C pillars. The chrome is gorgeous. It is actually metal plating so, you builders who worry about messing up the kit chrome with repeated handling...Worry not with this offering From Salvinos Jr. The roll cage tubing is also well proportioned compared to other offerings that covered this genre. Because of this kits original Petty car configuration...It comes with 3 different grill inserts for the front as well as one non chromed front bumper. It comes with 3 sets of rims one set of white plastic Steel wheels and two sets of proper NASCAR Rims...One of which is chromed. Also... You get the heads/intake rocker covers and front cover, oil pan and fan belt assembly to model the 355 CU.IN Small block that Nascar mandated after the 74 season. This particular kit also has components to model the 426 Hemi. The alternators in this kit (Yes you get two) Have molded in mounting bracket detail which is not to shabby and quite workable. The tires though not the greatest, lend themselves well to typical detail methods and are quite passable once dressed up. Another benefit with the generic kit is Power Slide makes a pretty wide range of Decal sets to model some significant and not so significant 71 to 74 Chargers from back in the day. Also, Model car garage has put out PE Sets for both the 71 to 73 and the 73 to 78 versions of this kit. Yeah... Some teams ran this body style into the 78 season since nothing else was aerodynamic enough to be competitive with the small displacement rules. Next installment we will discuss the bad...Stay tuned gang!!!
|
|
pete
Super Member
Registered: Jun 29, 2021 13:48:10 GMT -7
Posts: 409
|
Post by pete on Jan 5, 2022 18:10:50 GMT -7
The Bad: Body; Very little in the way of sink marks or blemishes in the plastic but. The door shut lines, disappear at the A pillars. This is also the mold separation point soo...Mold line I think is what obscured the shut line. The line was inaccurate though (What there was of it) Soo some re-engraving will be necessary if you intend to make a go of this kit for shows. The leading edge of the front fenders was also not correct. The kit rendered leading edge was a flat,straight line. Not supposed to be, they should taper in to the hood gap/fender line from outboard to inboard and match the front bumpers curvature/shape. Some re-work and shaping is necessary here but not a deal breaker. Power bulge hood...Nice! But...Many of these chargers ran a flat hood (The power bulge disrupted the air flow at the cowl diminishing the air pressure a bit) Soo a flat hood would be a nice option as well as more correct for most versions but...You don't get one. Ancillary components like Oil coolers, alternators and remote oil filter set up were very generic? They were not very well rendered or detailed. In short, very un-inspiring. I ended up fabbing my own remote oil filter assembly and added some mesh details to the oil coolers(They had none) I also fabbed a coolant overflow tank. This piece was on a parts tree but, a waste of time for the company to even bother putting in the mold.(But they did) Front suspension is very basic. These cars were basic! Once again bordering on generic. The front spindles are quite robust and wont be a breakage issue like the fragile things you get in some other kits with poseable steering. Front upper control arms are molded to the frame rails (This does preclude adjusting front ride height unless you get creative) That said...The front ride height is low, as it should be for a Stock car of this vintage! So not really an issue. Front wheels are retained by a plastic pin that passes through the spindle and fits tightly to the wheel back. (I didn't use em) The rear suspension...The multi piece axle housing is a bit under sized if you ask me. Axle tubes seem small diameter wise. Separate third member as well as rear cover are well detailed and fit nicely to the housing. The leaf springs...Once again, generic looking but do the job well. I was going to make my own but. You gotta stop somewhere! Salvinos gives you 8 lowering blocks for the rear that sandwich between the axle and the leaf springs. A nice touch I thought. I didn't use these either. The rear wheels are retained with a metal axle that is pushed into the wheel backs. Decals: Did I mention you get none? Nada, zip, zilch, nothing. I think they should have at least given you a set of tire lettering decals. The lack of decals does reflect in the price though. In my area these kits go for 30 to 39 dollars. Without the decals...26 to 30. The chrome: Its awesome! Vacuum plating at its finest! But... It does have some flash on the edges of the bumpers where it will be seen. Also the sprue gates on the front bumper are on top where you see em when the hood is open. If this was regular kit chrome, it wouldn't be much of an issue. This stuff is metal! You cant just trim off the flash. It has to be filed off. (Unless you want to chip that beautiful chrome) Same with the marks on the parts from the sprue gates. Its not the end of the world but this chrome being metal makes clean up/touch up more difficult than it needs to be. Also nothing in my arsenal matched the tone of the kit chrome. The rear deck spoiler, the kit piece is LOADED with ejector pin marks. I mean to the point of not being useable as is. Yeah its chrome too, I tried to strip it with easy off. No dice, didn't even touch it after 3 days of soaking in it. If you plan to use it, sand and file till you get a surface primer will adhere too. And you better use an etching primer...Its chrome, nothing will stick to it for long. Fill the pin marks and paint it...LOL (I didn't use it either)... The PE Parts from MCG come in handy here for the rear spoiler along with several other notable pieces that you will most likely want to include if you build one of these. The front lower valence mesh screen is a welcome addition that requires minimal and simple mods to install. The door handle block off plates are a nice touch that adds some depth to the model. The front chin spoiler is a bit fiddly and needs to be worked to get the lip bent and conformed to the shape of the lower valence, but looks great once its mounted. As a side note here, the kit supplied chin spoiler is well rendered and actually quite thin and looks quite nice as well. (if you don't feel like getting a piece of metal to fit). Either one will do the build justice. The P.E. parts come with mesh grill inserts that are very nice but...You will have to file them and re-shape them a bit to get em to fit the front bumpers grill cavities properly. I didn't use em...They just wouldn't conform and this kit sucked enough of my soul out of me at that point soo... I went with the kit plastic grill inserts which are also quite well done and fit without a lot of drama. The P.E parts come with a plethora of things you can use or hang on to for another build, just like most of Model Car Garages P.E. sets. It is a pricy set though 30.00 if I remember correctly. Next time: The ugly...Yeah...It is. Stay tuned!!!
|
|
pete
Super Member
Registered: Jun 29, 2021 13:48:10 GMT -7
Posts: 409
|
Post by pete on Jan 6, 2022 18:01:55 GMT -7
The ugly: The "C" Pillars on the body...They bulge out!! For how wonderful the Salvinos Jr kits are touted to be. This left me wondering if I should just put it in the parts car pile. This body is a brand new tool. I understand how this happened though. The mold for this 71/72 body is the same mold used for the 73/74 body. A different insert is placed in the mold, to change the shape of the quarter glass opening. Its a concession to versatility... I feel they should have done a better job with this, all things considered. Its the most glaring discrepancy since you cant help but see it. The chassis, I don't have an MPC Petty Charger kit handy to compare but...If the "Universal Chassis" in this Salvinos kit isn't Identicle to that awful MPC Chassis...Its pretty durn close and just as ugly. For the money, as well as the time Salvinos Jr kits have been on the market. I would have expected better of this latest offering for a chassis. Once again, a cost saving move in the name of versatility. The engine...Do your self a favor, build the small block offering. Its probably more accurate than the Hemi. Where to start: The NASCAR spec bath tub intake is flippin' amazing!!! Details on it are spot on and it just looks good!! It will fit perfectly on that 1/24 scale Hemi you don't know what to do with.(Note: This kit is 1/25 scale) Yes like the rest of this engine, its out of proportion. I get it.. Once again, a nod to cost savings. The engine block/transmission are for the small block (It will end up looking like a 440 with the distributor in the wrong place, size wise) Its also the same block used to build the faux Hemi. Its so wrong proportionally as well as appearance wise that I couldn't in good faith use it for the build. The quintessential Hemi Rocker covers (Probably the MOST Identifiable feature of a Hemi) Are just wrong, flat rectangles with Spark plug locations up the middle, and too many rocker cover bolts in the wrong places. Really? The rest of the details and proportions were just vestiges of a Hemi, like a cheap knock off. I had to use a Hemi from my parts stash. Maybe I'm just too picky but...I would gladly pay more money for an accurate representation with better details than what's in this box for 30 + dollars. Is it a terrible kit? No...It goes together rather well with few fitment issues and will look great built up and sitting on a shelf with all your other models and truthfully. Few will notice the discrepancies. But if you plan to build one for the show, its gonna take some work, unless you put it in the "Out of box" category. Soo, lousy engines...Bad universal chassis and bulging C pillars along with the lack of a proper flat hood aside... Only a purist will walk away from a purchase here. The rest of us see it as a challenge that must be met. Sorry for being soo long winded here but I felt it had to be said. LoL...The people deserve to know!! Hope it was informative or at least entertaining for everyone. Gotta figure out what the next project is gonna be now... See yah!!!
|
|
malcox477
Loyal Member
Registered: May 21, 2019 16:19:37 GMT -7
Posts: 1,039
|
Post by malcox477 on Jan 14, 2022 23:02:48 GMT -7
Thank you for the recap Pete, definitly there's a lot going on when come to do a review on a kit
|
|
pete
Super Member
Registered: Jun 29, 2021 13:48:10 GMT -7
Posts: 409
|
Post by pete on Jan 16, 2022 19:01:11 GMT -7
Your welcome Marcos. Sorry its such a long read but, I felt it had to be said on this one.
|
|
malcox477
Loyal Member
Registered: May 21, 2019 16:19:37 GMT -7
Posts: 1,039
|
Post by malcox477 on Jan 17, 2022 0:31:48 GMT -7
was a super review, to bad i don't do straight out of the box build to do stuff like this on my channel, but i can do that with parts and tool that i use, you give a great idea Pete
|
|